Material Selection

 WEEK 11: Materials for Design

In this lesson, we learnt how to select the correct material our product. Choosing the right material can be beneficial as it can lead to lower product costs, better performance, reduce environmental impact and allow the product to be safer for usage. (all the good stuff amirite?? ๐Ÿ‘ฝ๐Ÿ‘ป)

The most important factor to take into consideration when choosing materials is the characteristics of the materials. 

Material properties can be classified into many different categories, for example:

  • Mechanical properties ๐Ÿ’ช- strength, ductility, Young's modulus
  • Thermal properties ๐ŸŒก- thermal conductivity, specific heat capacity 
  • Fabrication properties ๐Ÿ‘š- ease of machining/ welding

There are 3 stages to select an appropriate material for your product:

  1. Define material requirements for the design (IDENTIFY the *function* of the product, then relate it to the material requirements) ๐ŸŽฏ
  2. Select & evaluate candidate materials (via the use of COWS ๐Ÿฎ)
  3. Choose the most economical material ๐Ÿค‘
Stage 1: 
function- what is the function of the product?
constraints- what are the properties the material needs to have for the product to serve its purpose?
objectives- which properties are more important?

Stage 2:
Use COWS method to rank the different properties and choose the material that is given the highest score

Stage 3:
research on the economic viability of the top 2/3 candidates from Stage 2 and choose the material that is the most cost-efficient

CA2 Report Part 1: Material Selection
My group was tasked to select materials for a disposable water bottle ๐Ÿšฐ that does minimal environmental harm ๐Ÿƒ

Click here๐Ÿ”— to look ๐Ÿ‘€at our material selection. 


WEEK 12: Design for Materials

Finding a material that suits the product requirement perfectly can be very difficult and costly, hence there are occasions where we ought to make changes to the product design so that a particular material can be used. For example, a hair dryer ๐Ÿ’จ that everyone is familiar with nowadays. Did you know that the hair dryers have at least 100 years of history? I bet you didn't!๐Ÿ˜†..But yes, the first hair dryer was created in the year 1890.

this was how hair dryers looked like in 1890. Will you use it? HAHAH (tbh i wouldn't cus it looks like my head is gonna get sucked in ๐Ÿ‘น๐Ÿ‘€)

Since the first design was too bulky and some clients hair take too long to dry up, modifications were made to the design in hopes to improve the product effectiveness. 


And again, the 2nd design was also a fail ๐Ÿ’ฅas it was still too heavy to be carried and there were many accidents involving overheating and electrocution⚡ because the casing was made with metal.

Fast forward a few years, the first portable hair dryer was finally invented and it was made out of only plastic and wood. (modifications were made to the design so that safer materials like plastic and wood can be used) 

don't you think this resembles the hair dryers we are using these days?

This example shows how changes can be made to a design so that a certain materials are usable.

CA2 Report Part 2: Design for materials 

After learning about the basics of design for materials, it was our turn to apply the knowledge on our report. 

We chose material called PORON foam to substitute the material used for helmets ๐Ÿ‘ท. PORON foam is more breathable as compared to HDPE that is normally used to manufacture helmets. By doing so, the user will feel more comfortable wearing the helmet. 

PORON foam material is also an excellent shock absorber. Hence, we had another idea that it can be used as the inner lining of a phone case ๐Ÿ“ฑto provide better protection (enhance the functionality of existing product: shock absorbing phone case) for the phone.
 




CA2 Report Part 3: Sustainable Design ๐Ÿšจ

Sustainable design is the approach to create products & services that are environmentally friendly ๐ŸŒ. We can make use of some sustainable design strategies, for example:

- using recycled materials 

- use energy efficient processes

-design for reuse & recycling (easy to disassemble)

In my opinion, I think that it is crucial❗ to take this design factor into consideration when coming up with product designs given today's context where global warming ๐Ÿ˜ทand sustainability is a huge topic that is being discussed a lot.

Click here๐Ÿ”—to look๐Ÿ‘€ at our report.


Practical 3: Properties of Material

For this practical, we were tasked to investigate a few different material properties, namely:

  1. Thermal conductivity ๐ŸŒก
  2. Surface tension ๐Ÿ’ข
  3. Young's Modulus ๐Ÿ”ž
  4. Viscosity of liquid ๐Ÿ’ฆ

My group carried out Experiment 3B, to determine the surface tension of water & water with 1 drop of detergent added. 

Surface tension is defined as the property of the surface of a liquid that allows it to resist an external force due to the cohesive nature of the water molecules. It is also classified as a physical property (๐Ÿ’ญrecall week 11 topic), in terms of material properties. 

Surface tension can be measured using various methods. Foer example, using Wilhelmy Plate, Pendant Drop and Du Nouy Ring. But for this practical session, we used the Du Nouy Ring ๐Ÿ’method.

Objective of experiment: to measure the mass required to tear the meniscus of different test liquids and to determine the surface tension of the liquid.

Experiment procedures:

1. Place the retort stand with a lever and a beaker on a flat surface


2. Fill the beaker with water such that the ring is 1-2mm submerged into the water.


3. Add load onto the weighing boat till the meniscus tears from the ring. (we used silica gel beads & some small pebbles ๐Ÿ—ฟ)



4. After the meniscus tears from the ring, measure the exact mass of load used using an electronic balance ⚖

5. After recording the necessary readings, repeat the experiment with 1 drop of detergent added to the water.

Calculations:


Results:
Based on our results, detergent decreases surface tension of the water. Molecules of the detergent moves to the surface of the water which resulted in weaker cohesive forces between the water molecules. Thus, less force is needed to break the meniscus from the ring, meaning surface tension of water decreases when 1 drop of detergent is added.

Reflection ๐Ÿ““:

During this practical session, I have came to realize the importance of surface tension in our daily lives. For example, it is used during detergent formulation where researchers make use of surface tension to find ways to improve cleaning properties of products. It is also used by paint companies to improve effectiveness of paints so that the paint products can be better tailored to different customers' demands. 

As for the experiment, I feel that we carried out the whole experiment quite smoothly. However, the lever balance we used was a limitation as it was hard to tell if the lever is parallel to the table top before adding the loads onto the weighing boat. This may lead to inaccuracy in results as there would be unequal moment about the pivot due to uneven balance.



Comments